Mini Review: P. Craig Russell's The Ring of the Nibelung
Written By The Wagnerian on Sunday 16 June 2013 | 4:53:00 am
"The comic-book artist P. Craig Russell sees the "Ring" as a crucial
evolutionary step in the development of superheroes as we know them
today. "I think it's a continuum -- from Ulysses to Wotan to Superman," LA Times: 2011 "Russell, whose recent credits include "Hellboy" and "Coraline," penned
his own comic-book version of the "Ring," a two-volume series published
in 2002 by Dark Horse Comics that he considers the most personal project
of his career. An opera fan, he has even spoken to gatherings of
so-called Ring Nuts, extreme fans of the "Ring" cycle. "It's almost like
going to a comic book convention -- you see the same faces," LA Times: 2011
Comic books (arguably a poor term anyway, but familiar to most) are a part of the narrative - or otherwise - arts sadly much maligned outside of the odd "intellectual" who may whisper quietly about their presence among their collections, but keep them well out of sight of prying eyes. Perhaps hidden behind rather attractive editions of Kant, Voltaire, Shelley, Shakespeare, or Goethe but most likely read as much - if not more. Now, why this is is another matter and one I have never been able to find adequately answered. In the UK, especially for a certain generation, it seems in part, to be because the word "comic book", is closely associated with publications such as "The Dandy" or "Beano". And indeed, the most hardened "fan" would struggle to find intellectual depth in either (although the odd sociologist or anthropologist might find much about "class status", "economic power relationships" and the subversion there of) . In the USA things are a tad different but hardly much. Superman, Batman, JLA, Spider-man, etc reign supreme. These are often comic books that seem to contain little more than the most basic narratives of "good over evil", semi pornographic "super heroes" (Poor old Red Sonja. No matter the feeble justification for her "bikini") and simplified heroic journeys (although again, there seems to be little narrative fiction that contains much else - despite how much some would like to hid it.). And again there is some truth in this "stereotype" with the number of artists and writers writing in the mainstream genre who are willing or indeed able to subvert it being small (Grant Morrison, Frank Miller, Alan Moore, Pat Mills, Garth Ennis, Dwayne McDuffie etc being a few of the exceptions).
Outside, of the "mainstream" however things are far different - even if some of these artists also work within it. P. Craig Russell' could not be described as a "subversive" in the same style as Morrison or Moore and neither is he an artist who uses the art form to explore ideas in the various ways that Art Spiegelman, Bryan Talbot or Marjane Satrapi might. However, one of the things that he has done, is to transfer some of the worlds greatest "operas" into lucid, well conceived "comics" - an unusual and welcome merging of art forms. Starting with Parsifal in 1979 he went on to produce many more opera adaptations including: Pelléas & Mélisande (the best visual representation of this opera in my opinion and his greatest work in his opera series), Salome and seemed to complete his "opera" graphic novels with what he considered his life long project; The Ring of the Nibelung.
Originally released as a monthly series by "Dark Horse Comics" between 2000 and 2001, the series can now be found in a two volume paperback set. Art work by Russell, coloured by his longtime collaborator Lovern Kindzierski, Wagner's "libretto" was fairly faithfully (given the very different medium) translated and adapted by Patrick Mason.
Given that as much, is taking place in Wagner's music as in the text (if not more and sometimes in opposition to that text) transposing this work to a purely "silent" medium should have been nearly impossible but somehow Russell does mange to do this far better than might be expected. How? In a number of ways that are difficult to describe, but involve his use of "silent" panels as much as framing and page layout. Being given a generous amount of space to allow him all of the narrative space he needs, helps greatly - as does Kindzierski's careful use of his color palette (and knowing when to restrain it).
Even those that have no interest in graphic novels as an art form but who do have an interest in Wagner's longest, and possibly most popular work should find much to enjoy.
On purge bébé
-
Philippe Boesmans’ last opera, On purge bébé, premiered at La Monnaie/De
Munt in Dember 2022, a few months after the composer’s death. It’s a one
act farce...
Los 100 de Maria, por siempre Callas
-
En la magia inextinguible de una voz imperfecta que cambió el destino del
canto – el aliento vital transformado en música -se hallan las claves para
intent...
Between gloom and glory: Lohengrin in the factory
-
The Dutch National Opera's new production places Lohengrin in a barren
factory hall. A place where amid the bleakness of everyday life the promise
of a mir...
Aotearoa New Zealand Watercolour Journey
-
Last month I posted about my New Zealand Sketchbook. I made it primarily
for my European friends, none of whom had been to my homeland, but when I
receiv...
Books as Objects as Well as Content
-
I’ve recently read two older Wagner books that lend insight not only into
their subject topics, but into the times in which they were written. These
are W...
Lahti
-
I am in Lahti, Finland, to give a talk at the Lahti Symphony's Sibelius
Festival. I've been wanting to visit since I encountered Osmo Vänskä's
revelatory B...
CFP: Leeds 2024 IMC Tolkien Sessions
-
*CFP: Leeds 2024 IMC Tolkien Sessions *
Paper abstracts are currently being sought for the following Tolkien
sessions for the International Medieval...
Comps for the MM in Mastersinging
-
Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg Deutsche Oper Berlin 29.6.22 In the era of
the hyperobject you almost have to salute a production that retains the
visual si...
-
Blog beëindigd. Leidmotief verkaste naar Substack, "the home of great
writing". Klik hier Blog discontinued. Leidmotief migrated to Substack,
"the home of ...
Lies
-
The truth shall set us free.
Okay, fine, except what happens when the truth is obscured in lies? That
now seems to be the situation in the United States....
Book Review: Blood and Iron by Katja Hoyer
-
A Review of Blood and Iron: The Rise and Fall of the German Empire
1871–1918 by Katja Hoyer
Amazon Kindle eBook edition (the edition used for the revi...
Sleeping Forever Beneath the Dry Earth (Part 5)
-
Shostakovich talking with Rudolf Barshai in the early 1970s
And here is the final part of my book. I am really pleased with a lot of
what's in this part ...
-
Ligeti, Atmosphères
Wagner, Prelude to Lohengrin Act 1
Berg, Violin Concerto
Brahms, Symphony No. 3 in F major
Vienna Philharmonic
Christoph von Dohnányi, ...
El desafío de Werther en Lima
-
*La magnífica ópera de Massenet, obra cumbre del romanticismo francés,
llega en una extraordinaria producción de la Ópera de Colombia, para abrir
la Tempo...
Twerp it.
-
Review – Salome (English National Opera, Friday 28 September 2018) Salome –
Allison Cook Jokanaan – David Soar Herod – Michael Colvin Herodias – Susan
Bick...
Royal Opera House announces Ring Cycles for 2018!
-
Very excited by this announcement. Must start saving now…. ADVANCE
ANNOUNCEMENT Four full cycles performed September–November 2018 The 2018/19
Season open...
continuing as the flying surgeon
-
As some of you may have noticed this blog has been inactive the last couple
of years. When I started this blog I worked in Denmark, but in 2011, after
I be...
The Most Terrifying Aria In All Of Opera
-
The most terrifying aria in all of opera, or why Mozart stands alone as a
composer of dramma per musica. (Our thanks to The Music...
-
*JULES BASTIN, BASSE CHANTANTE*
BASTIN was born in Waterloo in 1933. He was a Belgian operatic bass* who*
made his debut in 1960 at *La Monnaie*, singing ...
Carmen Aldrich
-
Carmen at Chorégie d’Orange was TV live broadcast less than two weeks ago.
Contrary to the Puccini operas or the dreaded Verismo repertoire, Carmen is
alwa...
All-Wagner Concert on Friday, May 21
-
Please join us for "Exquisite Love Duets and Solos by Richard Wagner," on
Friday, May 21, 2010, at Pickman Hall, Longy School of Music, Cambridge,
Massachu...